What is the best and healthiest canned cat food?

I was feeding my cats Chicken Soup For The Pet Lovers Soul canned cat food but the company cant seem to keep their formula consistant, so sometimes my cats will eat it and sometimes they wont. I am sick of going through this so I need to change cat foods. I wont use the Wellness brand because it contains garlic. I just had them try New Balance but that contains fish meal which is a by-product. I am clueless. And for those of you who are going to mention an all natural raw diet, that is not an option for me. Thanks!